Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Marketing Agency: 7 Red Flags

Checklist of questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency

Summary · 6 min read

The most important questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency cover strategy, contract terms, day-to-day management, proof of results, reporting and exit clauses; always separate the management fee from ad spend in writing before you sign anything. Independent agency-selection guidance backs up why this separation matters from day one.

  • Always separate agency fees from media spend
  • Confirm who manages your account daily
  • Make sure ad accounts stay in your name

Questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency decide whether you gain customers or lose months and budget on the wrong partnership. Many directors meet the friendly co-founder in the pitch, sign the contract, and never hear from that person again: a junior account manager takes over instead. This guide gives you the questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency that protect your revenue, your team’s time and your relationship with your own customers, and doubles as a practical answer to how to choose a digital marketing agency without guesswork. Established marketing consultants raise the same concerns, which is a useful sanity check when you compare proposals.

Why questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency matter

Asking the right questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency avoids three common losses: paying for generic tactics with no diagnosis of your real problem, losing access to your own ad accounts if the partnership ends, and discovering late that an all-inclusive price hid scope exclusions. Pricing structures vary widely between agencies, and understanding whether you are quoted a flat fee, a percentage of spend or a performance-based model changes how you compare offers, as pricing breakdowns from paid media specialists explain. Without this clarity, two proposals that look similar on paper can leave you paying very different amounts for the same results. Google’s own guide, Do you need an SEO?, lists the questions to ask before you hire.

Your scepticism is reasonable. Much of the information about digital marketing online is produced by agencies to sell their own services, leaving business owners without independent benchmarks to compare competing proposals. Bringing a written list of questions into the first meeting signals to any agency that you expect transparency, which tends to improve the quality of the answers you receive.

What are the marketing agency red flags before you sign?

These signs are red flags that show you have not yet asked the right questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency during the sales meeting:

  • The proposal arrived with no diagnosis of your business, website or competitors.
  • The monthly fee is one single number, with no split between management fee and ad spend.
  • Case studies show likes or impressions, not sales or enquiries.
  • No name or direct contact for the account manager was given.
  • The contract runs twelve months with no early exit clause.

The full checklist: questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency

Use this marketing agency contract checklist and list of questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency in your next meeting, and ask for answers in writing, not just verbally. Cover who owns your ad accounts and data if you part ways, how reporting is delivered and how often, what happens if targets are missed, and which team member you can contact directly without going through account management layers. Written answers protect you later if a dispute arises over scope, deliverables or fees, and they give you a clear record to compare against what the agency actually delivers once the contract begins.

QuestionWhy it matters for your businessRed flag answer
Do you diagnose before proposing tactics?Without a diagnosis, you pay for generic actions that may not solve your real sales problem.

Questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency about reporting and results

Ask how often you will receive reports, whether figures are shown as raw data or translated into revenue and enquiries, and whether you can request a call to walk through results whenever you need one. Agencies that hesitate to commit to a reporting schedule in writing are often the same agencies that struggle to show real return on investment later. Confirm too whether creative assets, campaign data and account logins remain yours if you decide to move on, since losing access to your own history at the end of a contract is one of the most common complaints from businesses that switched providers.

 

Questions by sector: adapt the checklist to your business

The core questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency work for any company, but each sector carries its own risks that are worth adding to the list.

Retail and ecommerce

Ask how the agency handles traffic peaks in high season and how it keeps the product feed in sync with your ads. An ecommerce performance audit before you sign shows where your shop loses sales before you spend more on advertising.

Professional services and healthcare

Ask how they approach local SEO and online bookings, which are essential for clinics, practices and offices that depend on showing up in Google Maps. See how local SEO for service businesses works.

Property and tourism

Ask how they deal with seasonality and whether they have experience selling to markets outside your own country, which is common in these businesses.

Management fee vs ad spend: the question most buyers forget

Among the questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency, the split between management fee and ad spend is the one most often forgotten and the most expensive to ignore. The total cost of running campaigns is never a single number: it is always two separate costs, the amount paid to the ad platform and the amount paid to the agency that manages the account.

Across international markets, management fees usually sit between 10% and 20% of monthly ad spend, often with a fixed monthly minimum. A healthy level for your business is one where the management fee stays below 15% of the revenue the agency is responsible for generating. Ask for this split in writing before you sign.

If you would rather check these answers with someone who has no commercial interest in your choice, you can book a free consultation and get an independent review before signing any contract.

How onOrbit Marketing can help

onOrbit Marketing answers the questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency with the same process it uses for every client: Diagnosis, Strategy, Implementation and Optimisation. In the Diagnosis stage we review your website, campaigns and competitors before proposing any tactic, with no invented success stories. The 360° Consulting service gives you a clear plan, with scope and costs listed separately, that you can use to compare proposals from any agency, including ours.

Frequently asked questions

What are the most important questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency?

The most important questions cover a prior diagnosis of your business, the split between management fee and ad spend, who actually manages your account, who owns the data and the exit clause in the contract.

How long does it take to see results from a marketing agency?

It depends on the channel: SEO usually takes a few months to show consistent results, while paid campaigns can produce data within weeks. Always ask for a realistic timeline and regular reports from the start.

Should ad accounts be in the client’s name or the agency’s?

Always in your company’s name. If an agency insists on keeping the accounts under its own ownership, you lose history, data and the ability to optimise if the partnership ends.

What should I do if my current marketing agency is not delivering?

Review the contract, ask for detailed reports by channel and check whether there is an exit clause. If nothing improves after agreed changes, use this checklist to assess alternatives before you renew.

Before you sign with any agency, get an independent diagnosis

Book a free consultation with onOrbit Marketing and get straight answers to the questions to ask before hiring a marketing agency, with no commitment.

Book a consultation

Photo of Alona Stepanova

Alona Stepanova

CEO of onOrbit Marketing | Web Developer & Specialist in E-commerce Growth. Helps SMEs and online stores in Portugal and across Europe grow with web development, SEO, GEO and digital marketing.